The Moon Shot That Would Have Gone Boom

The moon has always been humanity's silent companion, but few know how close we came to scarring it forever. During the darkest days of the Cold War, American military officials developed a classified plan that pushes the boundaries of imagination – Project A119, a serious initiative to detonate a nuclear weapon on the lunar surface.

Following the Soviet Union's launch of Sputnik in 1958, panic gripped Washington. America was falling behind in the space race, and the implications weren't just scientific, but existential. If the Soviets could master space, what might that mean for America's security? From this fear emerged an audacious plan championed by figures like General Homer Boushey – showcase American power by creating a nuclear explosion visible from Earth.

What makes this story particularly fascinating is the involvement of Carl Sagan, the beloved astronomer who would later inspire millions to look up at the stars with wonder. As a young scientist, Sagan calculated how lunar dust would behave during a nuclear blast, though something about the project troubled him deeply. The military wasn't asking what should be done, only what could be done. The moon wasn't a scientific frontier but a propaganda stage.

The plan was eventually abandoned, but it leaves us with profound questions about how close humanity has come to irreversible cosmic mistakes. What unknown catastrophes might have unfolded had the explosion triggered unexpected reactions in the lunar environment? The story of Project A119 serves as a sobering reminder of how fear can drive even the most advanced nations to contemplate the unthinkable. Subscribe now to hear more hidden stories from the intersection of science, politics, and human ambition.

 “Thank you for listening to Things I Want to Know.
You want these stories, and we want to bring them to you — so hit the support link and keep this circus, and the mics, alive.
Then do us a favor and rate and subscribe; it helps the show find more people like you — the ones who like their mysteries real and their storytellers unfiltered.
And if you want to wear a little of this madness, grab some Andrea-approved gear at paulgnewton.com.
We make t

Chapters

• 0:00 Cold War Lunar Nuclear Plot
• 1:13 Project A119 Unveiled
• 1:49 America's Space Race Anxiety
• 3:02 Carl Sagan's Secret Calculations
• 4:52 The Unasked Question: Should We?
• 5:42 Potential Lunar Catastrophe Avoided

Transcript

Speaker 1: 0:00

This special edition of Paul G's Corner and Things I Want to Know, brought to you ad-free by FMS Studios. There was a time, in the darkest days of the Cold War, when America almost did the unthinkable, when the moon was not a symbol of hope but a target, a symbol of power. The plan Detonate a nuclear bomb on the lunar surface. It's 1958. General Homer Boshi strode into a briefing room in the Pentagon, his boots clicking like a countdown. He didn't need to read the report. He knew what it said, what had to be done. This wasn't just a mission, it was a message, a message from the US military to the world. World. This project was codenamed A119, a study of lunar research flights, but beneath that innocuous title, I planned to fire a nuclear weapon to the moon. The science, it was secondary Spectacle, it was everything. The Cold War was a race. But this just wasn't about satellites and rockets. This was about control and perception, and that control, it was going to be shown with fire.

Speaker 1: 1:49

America was on the defensive. The Soviets launched Sputnik, the first artificial satellite, a milestone in space and a threat. If they could launch a satellite, what was next? A missile, a bomb? The Soviet Union was advancing fast. Their jets outclassed American aircraft. Their spies infiltrated Washington. The fear was real, and it wasn't just about national pride, it was about survival. The Soviets had already shown they could outpace America in the skies. How could they outpace us in space too? Could they reach the moon and claim it as their own? Americans couldn't afford to fall behind. What if they got there first? What if the moon, that silent witness to human ambition, became the front line of a new war? What if America's answer was a bomb sent to a place no one had ever touched but everyone has seen?

Speaker 1: 3:02

Inside the lab at the Illinois Institute of Technology, physicists sat with their team. The task Plan a nuclear explosion on the moon. Among them was Carl Sagan yes, that, carl Sagan. A young, eager scientist, a man who one day would look up to the stars and tell the world about the wonders of the universe. But here in this room, sagan wasn't looking up, he was calculating the unthinkable. His job was to predict the behavior of the lunar dust, the force of the blast. Would it create a visible cloud? Could the explosion be seen from Earth and could it be controlled? But something bothered him, something didn't sit right. What happens when you detonate a nuclear bomb on the moon. What happens when you detonate a nuclear bomb on the moon? No one knew for sure, but no one was asking either. Not really, because this wasn't about science. It was about ego, power and control.

Speaker 1: 4:18

America couldn't afford to lose the space race. Losing meant something much darker. It meant surrender. It meant the Soviets would hold the key to the future. The moon wasn't just a place in the sky, it was the ultimate prize.

Speaker 1: 4:37

And in that room, as men looked over the plans, the fear was palpable, because sometimes, when you're trying to prove you're the most powerful, you forget to ask the simple question should we? After months of preparation, someone at the Pentagon finally asked that question and they shut it down, but not before the plans were almost finished. So quietly, with no fanfare, no public announcement, they locked it away and the world never knew how close we came to making that lunar statement. The plan, it was real, it was on the table. But what if it just wasn't madness? What if it was the edge of something even darker that no one had considered?

Speaker 1: 5:53

The moon, silent as always, would have become a stage for catastrophe. What if the explosion triggered something? What if there was more to the moon than we understood. What if there were pockets of gas, methane or worse? No one had ever been there. So how could we actually know? Could we have knocked the moon out of orbit, causing massive tidal waves? Well, we'll never know. At least we hope not, and maybe that's a good thing, because sometimes the most dangerous questions are the ones that should never be asked. This episode is brought to you in conjunction with Things I Want to Know and Paul G's Corner. If you have questions or comments, please send them to paulg at paulgnewtoncom or just send me a message. Thank you.